What your team should GIVE UP to get Judd !
- Thread starter Richo
- Start date
MetallicA'
Ricky Davis Collector
Sylvia + Green + Miller + 1st Rd Pick 
hehe
hehe
white_chocolate_55
WhiteBoy
you win...
i wouldnt give up more than
bolton + draft pick early round
i wouldnt give up more than
bolton + draft pick early round
MetallicA'
Ricky Davis Collector
yeh its quite a lot but thats what will be required:
Off limits:
Davey, Travis J, Brock McLean, Yze, Bate, Whelan, Carroll, Pickett, Jmac
Off limits:
Davey, Travis J, Brock McLean, Yze, Bate, Whelan, Carroll, Pickett, Jmac
white_chocolate_55
WhiteBoy
hahaha good call.. i wouldn't take any of those duds.. well maybe the draft pick.. and "maybe" green..
Ryanm2117
Charles Oakley
Ling + King(Nearly finished) + Ottens(No real Value) + 1st Round(got top 5 talent from Father/Son Anyway.)
Would be more than happy for the cats to give them up for Judd!
Would be more than happy for the cats to give them up for Judd!
Ryanm2117
Charles Oakley
Seriously
Ling - Hard working Midfielder
King - Replace Gardiner
Steve Johnson/James Kelly- Bit of bait
1st Round Pick - Pick 7 or 8.
4
Chris Judd
Michael Gardiner (Is he still contracted
)
2nd Round Pick
Ling - Hard working Midfielder
King - Replace Gardiner
Steve Johnson/James Kelly- Bit of bait
1st Round Pick - Pick 7 or 8.
4
Chris Judd
Michael Gardiner (Is he still contracted
)2nd Round Pick
MetallicA'
Ricky Davis Collector
well if Judd demands to go to a certain team and they will only give up a certain few players than youd have to comply or get nothing for him. But he still has 1 year in his contract. so he may play his final year and sign to another club and you get nothing. if at the end of the year he says he will be returning to Melbourne i imagine he would get traded this year.
who know's, he might also be a player that wants to play his career out at 1 club but i hope thats not the case.
so he may play his final year and sign to another club and you get nothing. if at the end of the year he says he will be returning to Melbourne i imagine he would get traded this year.who know's, he might also be a player that wants to play his career out at 1 club but i hope thats not the case.
white_chocolate_55
WhiteBoy
I pass.. could get aker for a temp fix in the meantime until we draft our own midfielder
MetallicA' said:well if Judd demands to go to a certain team and they will only give up a certain few players than youd have to comply or get nothing for him. But he still has 1 year in his contract.
who know's, he might also be a player that wants to play his career out at 1 club but i hope thats not the case.
You don't get it dude......if he does want to go he won't leave the WCE in the sh*t.......even if he plays on next year (to the end) it doesn't mean the WCE will get nothing ! All he has to do is say...trade me to one of these three teams and BINGO the WCE have leaverage ! The only way WCE will get nothing is if he disagrees who the WCE want to trade him to.
MetallicA'
Ricky Davis Collector
I know that, Judd wouldnt do that to the team/state that have adopted him as one of their own. Maybe your right 
I would probally give:
Cam Bruce, Brad Green, Brad Miller and a 1st Round Draft Pick
for
Chris Judd, 2nd Round Draft Pick
---
Id love to see
Judd, TJohnstone, B.McLean, Jmac running our midfield!!
I would probally give:
Cam Bruce, Brad Green, Brad Miller and a 1st Round Draft Pick
for
Chris Judd, 2nd Round Draft Pick
---
Id love to see
Judd, TJohnstone, B.McLean, Jmac running our midfield!!
white_chocolate_55
WhiteBoy
This is what I think...
McVeigh + Welsh + Hille + 1st round Draft Pick
for
Judd + Gardner
otherwise, the only team I think could capture judd would be.. the lions..
so there would have to be a 3way trade
S. Black --> West Coast
Brodie Holland --> West Coast
Robert Copeland --> West Coast
Lockyer --> West Coast
Chris Tarrant --> Brisbane
Gardner --> Brisbane
Swan --> Brisbane
Judd --> Collingwood
McDougall --> Collingwood
West Coast 2nd rnd pick --> Collingwood
McVeigh + Welsh + Hille + 1st round Draft Pick
for
Judd + Gardner
otherwise, the only team I think could capture judd would be.. the lions..
so there would have to be a 3way trade
S. Black --> West Coast
Brodie Holland --> West Coast
Robert Copeland --> West Coast
Lockyer --> West Coast
Chris Tarrant --> Brisbane
Gardner --> Brisbane
Swan --> Brisbane
Judd --> Collingwood
McDougall --> Collingwood
West Coast 2nd rnd pick --> Collingwood
MetallicA'
Ricky Davis Collector
Im sure West Coast would take my offer over your Richmond one.
Coughlan gets injured every year
Coughlan gets injured every year
Yeah but he is a good midfielder who is from WA......I remember when WCE picked Judd.....I was SPEWING I wanted Polak but I guess they got it right but the whole I want to go home thing STILL annoys me from the Gherig days.....and more recently McConnell to the Kangaroos !
Similar threads
