With the winner being crowned tomorrow, this is what I've come up with so far. It's a scale of patch grading everyone should be using by now, the HPGS (Hacka Patch Grading System)

. Tags are out, just patches are in. If there are multiple patches the score given will be an average of all patches. Only one entry chosen per participant. If a winner decides not to want the prize, the prize will be offered to the next in line and so on.
Centering: How it looks on the card, subjective score /10
Shape: How the patch actually looks, subjective score /10. If it's curvy, has some nice directional changes, is a part of some type of logo it will get a higher score.
Matches the picture of the player: I'm of the opinion all patches should match the uni depicted. 10 if it matches, 5 if it doesn't but is the same team, 0 if not the same team
Game-used: Game-used gets 10, event worn gets 5, manufactured gets 0
Colour breaks: How many times the patch changes colour, either vertically or horizontally. 10 points for 6 or more, 8 for 5, 6 for 4, 4 for 3, 2 for 2, and 0 for 1.
Amount of colours: 10 points for 5 or more, 7 for 4, 4 for 3, 1 for 2
Each score out of 70 will be adjusted to a percentage score.
Finalist 1
@kiwi_in_melb
Centering: 10
Shape: 10
Matches the picture of the player: 5
Game-used: 10
Colour breaks: 10
Amount of colours: 4
= 49/60 = 81.67%
Finalist 2
@TheCardMan
Centering: 10
Shape: 10
Matches the picture of the player: 10
Game-used: 5
Colour breaks: 10
Amount of colours: 4
= 49/60 = 81.67%
Finalist 3
@Parrapaul
Centering: 10
Shape: 7
Matches the picture of the player: 5
Game-used: 5
Colour breaks: 10
Amount of colours: 7
= 44/60 = 73.33%
Finalist 4
@Ardog
Centering: 10
Shape: 10
Matches the picture of the player: 5
Game-used: 5
Colour breaks: 10
Amount of colours: 4
= 44/60 = 73.33%
Finalist 5
@suihon
Centering: 10
Shape: 7
Matches the picture of the player: 5
Game-used: 10
Colour breaks: 8
Amount of colours: 4
= 44/60 = 73.33%
Finalist 6
@wasportsfan1
Centering: 7
Shape: 10
Matches the picture of the player: 10
Game-used: 10
Colour breaks: 10
Amount of colours: 4
= 51/60 = 85.00%
Finalist 7
@Jordan_Cards_Fan
Centering: 10
Shape: 7
Matches the picture of the player: 10
Game-used: 10
Colour breaks: 8
Amount of colours: 4
= 49/60 = 81.67%
Finalist 8
@nichj99
Centering: 10
Shape: 8
Matches the picture of the player: 10
Game-used: 10
Colour breaks: 10
Amount of colours: 7
= 55/60 = 91.67%
These are all amazing, as well as others that haven't been through the HPGS treatment as well. I think I might just poll the patches that got over 80% and let the public decide the best one! It's not too late to add an entry if any of these can be beaten!