rishgoon
OzCardTrader
201cm Angus Graham joins Adelaide from Richmond. Do we still bring in Jesse White?? Time for some other clubs to get involved in the KT trade.
2012 AFL Off-Season Thread
- Thread starter Billyhoyle
- Start date
Matty76
Banned User
Good luck to Clinton Young - he was always a whipping boy at Hawthorn, hope he has a good career at Collingwood. I will never forget the 70m goal to put Hawthorn in front in the 2nd quarter of the 2008 Grand Final. In a lot of ways I like free agency - the amout of money that is turned over in footy these days means that there are opportunities opening up everywhere for players...and in the rest of society employees can choose to change their occupation where necessary/practical and being an AFL player is a full-time occupation.
BLOWN8
Such is life!
Not your house Darren?
lol, good one Luke. Not my place but know how he feels.
willc1986
OzCardTrader
Gumbleton signs new 1 year deal with bombers
wolvesjr34
Morrow Super Collector
Troy Chaplin and Daniel Pearce are worth picks 30 and 31 in compensation, CLinton Young a Prmeiership player and Grand FInalist poached by Collingwood... is worth pick 66? Uhh yeah AFL's bias against Hawthorn is VERY clear.
No compensation for losing Tom Murphy at all, he as an emergency to two grand finals, such AFL NONSENSE as usual.
No compensation for losing Tom Murphy at all, he as an emergency to two grand finals, such AFL NONSENSE as usual.
I used to get upset when players left Collingwood Especially when Tarrant went to fremantle, Fraser to suns call them traitors ect. But its life players like /need change and if they want to chase money thats fine we need to remember these guys get 10 years max in this profession to make the most out of it. If they stop performing the clubs have no hesitation delisting them. If Fraser stayed at Pies he would still be on there list not retired. TIME TO STOP HATING ON PLAYERS FOR CHANGING CLUBS.
(If Cloke left I wouldn't of liked it but id rather him go than play for us for the next five years hating the club.)
Loyalty in Football is a dying thing we are just slower that US to get there.
(If Cloke left I wouldn't of liked it but id rather him go than play for us for the next five years hating the club.)
Loyalty in Football is a dying thing we are just slower that US to get there.
Matty76
Banned User
As a Hawthorn member I don't begrudge blokes like Clinton Young and Tom Murphy moving to other clubs. We have been extremely ruthless at times with loyal players like Trent Croad and Campbell Brown and it is really a case of swings and roundabouts. Loyalty in footy is a myth anyway, dating back to Ron Barrassi leaving Melbourne to go to Carlton. It is a "supply and demand" situation - I am certain that if the Hawks were offered Murphy and Kruezer from Carlton or Dangerfield and Thompson from Adelaide as a straight swap for Youngy and Murph they would pack the two Hawks off without hesitation!
Billyhoyle
Im Not Juan Garcia
put simply - like free agency - hate compensation
Sharod and Lance enjoying themselves in New York.
Buddy Franklin â€@Buddy_Franklin
No better city then new York with my boys@sharrodw_21 lala boy gibson pic.twitter.com/ego1EJ3Y
Buddy Franklin â€
No better city then new York with my boys
ShueyGaffDarlingNat
Eagles Collector & AFL Connoisseur
Sharod and Lance enjoying themselves in New York.
Buddy Franklin â€@Buddy_Franklin
No better city then new York with my boys@sharrodw_21 lala boy gibson pic.twitter.com/ego1EJ3Y
Yup, BFF. What's that you say? Buddy is a free agent at the end of 2013 ?
Welcome to the Eagles Sharrod.
BLOWN8
Such is life!
Spot on, we get ripped again. Not too sure how they work this one out, its pretty clear we have been dealt a blow with the compensation here
willc1986
OzCardTrader
Koby Stevens to Bulldogs
Greg Broughton to Suns
Jordan Russell to Magpies
David Rohan to Demons
Greg Broughton to Suns
Jordan Russell to Magpies
David Rohan to Demons
willc1986
OzCardTrader
Crows should get shafted as well. They are just as guilty. If you have a gentlemens agreement, you should honour it. They have shot themselves in the foot. Tippurt should get banned for 2 years, manager should be banned for two years and Adelaide should loose their draft picks for this draft. Which means they will go into next year with 3 less players than everyone else.
One less team for the bombers to worry about next year.
One less team for the bombers to worry about next year.
matty83
#gocrows
Bit harsh, considering nothing has been proven yet mate. Only speculation at the moment
Scotty_WCE
West Coast card collector!
Adelaide and Tippett are jokes. Waste of Tippett's talent. Whatever punishments they get, they deserve...
Yeah. I know. Desperate for Bombers to start the season well and we have Crows at adelaide. Might be clutching at straws.....
matty83
#gocrows
Still finding it tough to get over the NAB cup loss champ?
BLOWN8
Such is life!
Big things happening in the trade with less than 2 hours to go.
Hawks news
Got Matt Spanger from Syd (ex West Coast, back-up key defender, Murphy replacement???)
Gilham to either Carlton or GWS is the talk
Personally id like Gilham to stay, but not too sure he'd get a good run in the seniors next year.
I guess if he does leave we will get another crap compo pick from the AFL. Surely if Chaplin is worth a pick in the 30's then a premiership fullback still only 28 is worth more.
Hawks news
Got Matt Spanger from Syd (ex West Coast, back-up key defender, Murphy replacement???)
Gilham to either Carlton or GWS is the talk
Personally id like Gilham to stay, but not too sure he'd get a good run in the seniors next year.
I guess if he does leave we will get another crap compo pick from the AFL. Surely if Chaplin is worth a pick in the 30's then a premiership fullback still only 28 is worth more.
