This is the best they could come up with?

Ja$e

To infinity and beyond...

Feedback - 100%

202   0   0

• Sep 13, 2006

• #1

I was shocked and appalled on Sunday after witnessing Brodie Holland clean up Montgomery, it was prob the most cowardly act I have ever seen because of how deliberite it was! I had the feeling of walking onto the ground and decking him. Anyway this is there basis for appeal.

Collingwood has appealed on the basis that no Tribunal acting reasonably could have reached this verdict.

Morons!

 

Pierce34

Paul Pierce Collector

Feedback - 97.2%

70   2   0

• Sep 13, 2006

• #2

he deserves everything he gets after that display

 

Allstar cards inc

"Got one more than Shaq!"

Feedback - 100%

132   0   0

• Sep 13, 2006

• #3

Collingwood has appealed on the basis that no Tribunal acting reasonably could have reached this verdict.

Morons!

Click to expand...

Exactly...no team or player acting reasonably should behave like that on the field....let the 6 weeks act as a deterrent to other clubs and their players.

 

Benny J

Mr Big Shot...

Feedback - 100%

95   0   0

• Sep 14, 2006

• #4

Does anyone have a link where i can see the incident. I have heard about it but would love to see it?

 

Richo

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

415   0   0

• Sep 14, 2006

• #5

Pierce34 said:

he deserves everything he gets after that display

Click to expand...

Agreed ! I was pretty annoyed when I saw it, I knew he would go

 

Ja$e

To infinity and beyond...

Feedback - 100%

202   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #6

And he deservedly gets 6! Whats the bet he comes in at round 7 and does it again! Moron!

 

theflyinggerco

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

91   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #7

Hell yeah, not only does it show the other players in the AFL that stuff is not going to tolerated... still dont know how Didak's hit from behind wasn't considered dangerous, but thats the inconsistent tribunal.

 

mattyj

Multi-Player Collector

Feedback - 100%

189   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #8

hahaha sucked in crapingwood ....i think he shoulda gotten 10 coz buckley and didak got off the week before, but what can you do?

 

white_chocolate_55

WhiteBoy

Feedback - 100%

21   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #9

yeah the tribunal hasnt acted accordingly, so give him 8 due to the stupidity of appealing this incident..

 

theflyinggerco

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

91   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #10

I still dont understand what was going through didaks mind, "stuff the tackle, im going the dirty, from behind, dangerous hit"? i dont understand that

Also these players have to remember that kids watch they play, and try and imitate them, as much as they say that they are not responsible, they are, so actions such as Holland's imitation of a cannon ball and Didak's hit need to be harshly dealt with to protect the other players and show kids the right way to play...

 

white_chocolate_55

WhiteBoy

Feedback - 100%

21   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #11

didak or holland?

 

Magicman

Banned User

Feedback - 100%

194   0   0

• Sep 15, 2006

• #12

he got 6 weeks, was a stupid act lets get over it lol!!!!

 

Richo

OzCardTrader

Feedback - 100%

415   0   0

• Sep 16, 2006

• #13

Nah - I am glad his appeal was thrown out