Ozcards Top 10 AFL Players of ALL TIME

Farmer2Goggin2Wade

Farmer2Goggin2Wade

R.I.P Captain Beefheart!
Feedback - 100%
113   0   0
Hi guys I really enjoyed seeing the results for jimboiitmac thread Ozcards Top 10 Players in the NBA Thread and hingey242's OZcards Top 10 NBA Players of ALL TIME.
So I thought it would be interesting if we do a top 10 AFL Players of ALL TIME name your top 10 in order and I will keep a posted score on the first post thanks.

I'll start it off:

1. Gary Ablett Snr
2. Leigh Matthews
3. Wayne Carey
4. Tony Lockett
5. Ted Whitten
6. Graham Farmer
7. Jason Dunstall
8. John Nicholls
9. Kevin Bartlett
10. Greg Williams

THE LIST:

1. Leigh Matthews 70pts
2. Gary Ablett Snr 68pts
3. Wayne Carey 56pts
4. Tony Lockett 47pts
5. Graham Farmer 36pts
6. James Hird 31pts
7. Ted Whitten 29pts
8. Ron Barassi 26pts
9. Jason Dunstall 23pts
10. John Coleman 22pts

Just missed the cut:

11. Bob Skilton 12pts
12. Haydon Bunton Snr 10pts
13. Chris Judd 10pts
14. Greg Williams 8pts
25. John Nicholls 8pts
16. Ian Stewart 7pts
17. Kevin Bartlett 5pts
18. Gordon Conventry 4pts
19. Michael Voss 4pts
20. Michael Tuck 3pts
21. Peter Matera 1pt
 
This is a bit tough as there are a lot of great players that I have only heard of in reputation and never seen play...so I will tend to rate the players I've seen play higher than ones on reputation.

1. Garry Ablett Sr
2. Leigh Matthews
3. John Coleman
4. James Hird
5. Ted Whitten
6. Polly Farmer
7. Wayne Carey
8. Dick Reynolds
9. Tony Lockett
10. Kevin Bartlett

I know I well get some flack about this, especially Hird, but he is the best player I have seen the FULL career of. As great as Plugger was, I will always have the vision of that failed comeback in my head.

You did well Liam, I know my Club bias has come out, probably because I am more aware of the players from my club, But the 2 Geelong players you put in really should appear in every Top 10. Ablett was just a freak of nature, best player I have ever seen...(not even close) and Polly changed the game of football with the way he used handball.

---------- Post added 27-05-2011 at 10:26 PM ----------

TOp ten current players would be a good list to do, and probably easier to put together.
 
1. Leigh Matthews
2. Gary Ablett Snr
3. Wayne Carey
4. Tony Lockett
5. Jason Dunstall
6. Graham Farmer
7. John Coleman
8. Michael Tuck
9. Michael Voss
10. James Hird
 
1. Gary Ablett Snr
2. Leigh Matthews
3. Wayne Carey
4. Tony Lockett
5. Jason Dunstall
6. Greg Williams
7. John Coleman
8. James Hird
9. Michael Voss
10. Ted Whitten
 
1. wayne Carey
2. Gary Ablett snr
3. Topny lockett
4. Ron barrasi
5. bobby Skilton
6. Leigh Matthews
7. Gordon Coventry
8. Jason Dunstall
9. Greg Williams
10. James hird
 
1. Ron Barassi
2. Leigh Matthews
3. Polly Farmer
4. Chris Judd
5. Tony Lockett
6. Gary Ablett Snr
7. Bob Skilton
8. Wayne Carey
9. John Coleman
10.Ted Whitten
 
The players I have seen

1. James Hird
2. Chris Judd
3. Wayne Carey
4. Tony Lockett
5. Michael Voss
6. Jason Dunstall
7. Gary Ablett Snr
8. Gary Ablett Jnr
9. Peter Matera
10. Dermott Brereton

The players on Reputation

1.Leigh Matthews
2.John Coleman
3.Polly Farmer
4.Peter Hudson
5.Gordon Coventry
6.Kevin Bartlett
7.Ian Stewart
8.Ted Whitten Snr
9. Michael Tuck
10. Bob Skilton

edited for accuracy.
 
1. Haydn Bunton, Sr.
2. Dick Reynolds
3. Graham Farmer
4. Ian Stewart
5. Gary Ablett Snr
6. Ted Whitten
7. John Coleman
8. James Hird
9. Tony Lockett
10. Ron Barassi

Honorable Mention
Wayne Carey
Jason Dunstall
Peter Matera
Leigh Matthews
Chris Judd
Gordon Coventry
Michael Voss

Dalbs said:
Not a final but, loved that game at skilled in 06 too, I think what comeback of 53 points.
Click to expand...
that was a week after they beat Carlton by 44 I think
 
1. Leigh Matthews
2. Gary Ablett SNR
3. Ron Barrasi
4. Wayne Carey
5. James Hird
6. John Nicholls
7. Ted Witten
8. Chris Judd
9. Bob Skilton
10.Tony Lockett
 
1. Nathan Buckley
2. Gordon Coventry
3. Peter Daicos
4. Peter McKenna
5. Len Thompson
6. Dane Swan
7. Darren Millane
8. Tony Shaw
9. Gavin Brown
10. Alan Didak

Might be a little bias towards my team:D
 
1. gary ablett snr
2. Leigh Matthews
3. robert harvey
4. bob skilton
5. polly farmer
6. chris judd
7. michael voss
8. tony lockett
9. jonathon brown
10. jimmy bartel
 
its hard but heres mine
1.ben cousins
2.john worsfold
3.nathan buckley
4.wayne carey
5.chris mainwaring (R.I.P)
6.mark riccuito
7.james hird
8.michael voss
9.glen jakovich
10.peter matera
i liked watching them playing and youtubing some coz i didnt get to see em play but there tough and have a great style its awesome
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

GarnettFan4Life
ChatGPT ranks the Top 100 players of all time
Replies
13
Views
5,562
Dodgydave
D
Back
Top Bottom