i knew it i was saying it from the start idris cant defend! denfence wins origins! waste of space
a team without idris is a damn good team! 1 tackle made. and 2!! MISSED TACKLES THAT LEAD TO TRIES! and he didnt even do anything for the try he scored!
You've gotta be kidding me! They hardly went to him when he finally gets ON the field, he misses 2 WHOLE tackles, and he's the reason they lost??? Maybe the should've just made it the Paramatta team vs QLD, huh??? How about Hayne's 2 missed tackles, and 1 ineffective tackle?
Anyway, Lyon in the halves was a predictable dud move, neither he or Kimmorley really stood up, and I'd be happy for 2 young fellas to get a shot in the halves next time. Maybe Carney, and either Pearce, Mullen, or Tim Smith. And they've gotta get Hayne back to full-back where he belongs, and either drop Gidley entirely, or start him off the bench as a utility... Watmough needs his head examined, he physically CAN'T seem to keep his hands/knees away from the ball! And in general, the entire forward pack needs to harden up! All this damn talk about fire & brimstone, putting it on the QLD pack, targetting Lockyer and Thurston, and what do they DO??? Not bloody much! Either they were told by the coach to not start anything, not give away any penalties; or they're a bunch of damn skirts! When someone put up that video of Creagh with the tutu spliced in, I thought it was a bit harsh initially. But after that game, it seems pretty much dead on!
In short, I think NSW needs: 2 SPECIALIST halves; Hayne at full-back; Gidley on the bench or gone; start Idris, and possibly rotate hime into the forwards, maybe at lock, for short spurts; keep Ennis, but have Farrah on the bench as he can also give one of the halves a rest if needed; and a harder attitude/game by the forwards as a whole! Even if you have to bring back Mason and maybe Poore. And maybe slap Perry a few times just before kickoff to ark him up a bit, he was brought in for aggression but left it in Manly!
IMO sorry mate but both the tries were Haynes fault and the commentators even said that as well
Your right axeman.....It was interesting the forwards were very quiet in a game were nothing should have been left behind. Did anyone really charge full tilt into them......you know psychotic like, frothing from the mouth with their eyes rolling back and screaming....... no it was meant to be a mistake free grind....origin needs to be explosive not purely percentage footy.
I'm not sure what Bellamy's game plan was but I sure didn't see anything inspiring....time for him to go because he has been the one constant throughout all these loses.
Ross
PS Wouldn't Carney and Smith be a bad boy pairing.......
a team without idris is a damn good team! 1 tackle made. and 2!! MISSED TACKLES THAT LEAD TO TRIES! and he didnt even do anything for the try he scored!
You've gotta be kidding me! They hardly went to him when he finally gets ON the field, he misses 2 WHOLE tackles, and he's the reason they lost??? Maybe the should've just made it the Paramatta team vs QLD, huh??? How about Hayne's 2 missed tackles, and 1 ineffective tackle?
Anyway, Lyon in the halves was a predictable dud move, neither he or Kimmorley really stood up, and I'd be happy for 2 young fellas to get a shot in the halves next time. Maybe Carney, and either Pearce, Mullen, or Tim Smith. And they've gotta get Hayne back to full-back where he belongs, and either drop Gidley entirely, or start him off the bench as a utility... Watmough needs his head examined, he physically CAN'T seem to keep his hands/knees away from the ball! And in general, the entire forward pack needs to harden up! All this damn talk about fire & brimstone, putting it on the QLD pack, targetting Lockyer and Thurston, and what do they DO??? Not bloody much! Either they were told by the coach to not start anything, not give away any penalties; or they're a bunch of damn skirts! When someone put up that video of Creagh with the tutu spliced in, I thought it was a bit harsh initially. But after that game, it seems pretty much dead on!
In short, I think NSW needs: 2 SPECIALIST halves; Hayne at full-back; Gidley on the bench or gone; start Idris, and possibly rotate hime into the forwards, maybe at lock, for short spurts; keep Ennis, but have Farrah on the bench as he can also give one of the halves a rest if needed; and a harder attitude/game by the forwards as a whole! Even if you have to bring back Mason and maybe Poore. And maybe slap Perry a few times just before kickoff to ark him up a bit, he was brought in for aggression but left it in Manly!
