Is the case broken, I'm just wondering how the label could be torn?
EDIT:
Found some stuff on Google, and if what I am finding is true, is that these cases were sold as a snap-together case, or a DIY grading case. Alan Hager was the guy who started ACU-Card Inc, and was either bought out by PSA or paid-off or so I'm reading on some forums (something about his cases being similar to PSA cases, only PSA is a more permanent thing). So I really don't know the creditation behind that, only what I'm reading.
http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=75741
Fair few years old those posts....
I guess just be wary when selling that Olajuwon, if what I've found is true, you don't want a buyer to receive it and see that it's some mock-up job of a grading company, and want their money back.
Cheers